A perfect woman? Impossible…

As a society, we love the media. Sometimes it seems like entertainment is the only reason to live. (Grey’s Anatomy…Hero’s…come on!) However, sometimes we have to question certain myths and stereotypes that arises that inevitability affect our society. Dr. Mary-Lou Galician’s text, “Love Sex & Romance in the Media,” once again focuses on a stereotype that has affected our society for ages.

“To attract and keep a man, a woman should look like a model or a centerfold.”

Courtesy from Maxim.comIn entertainment, there are beauties galore. From the fashion world, to movies, TV, book covers … even the hand models for lotion. It’s a huge stereotype that has affected real-life relationships and self-perception resulting in hazardous health and depression.

According to Dr. Galician’s text, “Unrealistic Playboy-style pictures of attractive women can have attitudinal and behavioral effects on men and on their real-life relationships. Real women can’t measure up to these seemingly real fantasies.” Unfortunately, this also affects young girls who feel they have to grow up to a certain irrational standard of beauty. On the flip-side, young males are also depicted as having to always have muscular body-builder bodies as oppose to feminized male physique.

Dr. Galician did a survey at Arizona State University on this particular question. Very few men or women agree that woman should look like a model or centerfold to attract and hold a man. As a result, within those small percentages men are far more likely to agree (around 15%-compared with only around 3% of the women).

Courtesy from USATODAY.com

Photo on the left by By Bru Garcia, AFP/Getty Images. USATODAY .com said the picture is of models who were to wait backstage during a Madrid fashion week. The Madrid fashion show, which ended Saturday, banned overly thin models, saying it wanted to project beauty and health. Organizers said models had to be within a healthy weight range.

USATODAY.com wrote an article asking if thin models warped girls’ body image. An excerpt from the article said, “The promotion of the thin, sexy ideal in our culture has created a situation where the majority of girls and women don’t like their bodies,” says body-image researcher Sarah Murnen, professor of psychology at Kenyon College in Gambier, Ohio. “And body dissatisfaction can lead girls to participate in very unhealthy behaviors to try to control weight.”

For the folks that absolutely have to look like the cover model or the actresses on TV, there are actually self-help websites, blogs, books that say, “How to look like a Model.”

One blogger posted several pictures of celebrities without their make-up trying to prove how powerful make-up can be. This posted received a comment from an anotomyous blogger who said,

“Totally true. Plus a good hairstylist, good lighting, and good photography can make anyone look, if not glamorous, at least arty. When I was a kid, my father did some professional photography (really high quality stuff). He made everyone look beautiful or, for those with atypical proportions, visually striking. And I still use some of the tricks I picked up during a brief modeling stint 30 some years ago. Even now, I can look much “hotter” than I really am, though it takes more effort than I usually care for.”

Another blogger from NYC posts her own experiance. She wrote, “I wish I could believe that appearances don’t really matter, but we all know they do.” She goes on and mentions an encounter with a friend who constantly apologized for not looking as “hot” as she used to. She wrote, “After eighteen years of marriage, the wife of this ridiculously ripped man kept prefacing sentences with, “I know it’s hard to believe, but I was a catch when he found me” or “I used to be much thinner”. She felt like she had to apologize to the world for her appearance, even though she had found a beautiful man to love her. Now, no one rolls out of bed looking perfect.

Nicely put.

After the recent post, Cristina, a blogger, posted a comment in reaction to what I had to say:

Comment: “Gee, well…. it’s really hard. But I’ve started to accept my body, even though I can’t say it out loud, I just think I do. I’ve suffered from Anorexia since age 14 (I’m 27 now and recently entered treatment last June) and sure the media does tell women how they should look and how it will make them happy and crap. But it’s all a lie.”

Here’s my question to Cristina’s response:

Q: I’m glad you are in treatment and started to accept your body. If you don’t mind me asking, was one of the reason why you suffered from Anorexia as a young girl due to what you saw from the media?

The URI to TrackBack this entry is: http://lereflection.wordpress.com/2007/10/31/a-perfect-woman-impossible/trackback/

RSS feed for comments on this post.

13 Comments Leave a comment.

  1. On October 31, 2007 at 4:17 am Cristina Said:

    Gee, well…. it’s really hard. But I’ve started to accept my body, even though I can’t say it out loud, I just think I do. I’ve suffered from Anorexia since age 14 (I’m 27 now and recently entered treatment last June) and sure the media does tell women how they should look and how it will make them happy and crap. But it’s all a lie.

  2. On October 31, 2007 at 6:09 am Darkspell Said:

    I’m glad you are in treatment and started to accept your body. If you don’t mind me asking, was one of the reason why you suffered from Anorexia as a young girl due to what you saw from the media?

  3. On November 1, 2007 at 3:55 am Cristina Said:

    It wasn’t the media. For me it’s about control. Well, I think some of it has to do with control. Being able to control what you put in your body, and how much. Where you decide to eat, if you decide to eat, how little or how much… and everything around it.

  4. On November 6, 2007 at 8:48 pm cn2007 Said:

    Hey! This is a great blog post. It’s so true that “the perfect woman” is pretty much impossible. I never took Galician’s class, but the topics that you’re discussing here are pretty interesting and very relevant — even today, sadly.

    Nice work on the blog!

  5. On November 8, 2007 at 7:03 am Darkspell Said:

    So since you think it’s all about control on what you eat, how you eat etc, how has that treatment been effecting you? As for the media….since you don’t think it was the media that affected you in anyway, since you commented before on how the media shows and views how women should look, do you constantly tell yourself that it’s all fake?

  6. On November 8, 2007 at 7:13 am Darkspell Said:

    Cassandra, in your opinion … why is the “perfect woman” simply impossible? Have you ever been through any situations or moments in your life that may have led you to this conclusion?

  7. On November 8, 2007 at 8:03 pm cn2007 Said:

    I don’t know… I think it’s just the subsconscious knowledge that a person has to look a certain way to get a guy’s attention, or to be considered beautiful by society.

    And, once a woman achieves those goals (assuming she can), then she can’t be too intelligent. For some men — and women — intelligence is intimidating. At the same time, women who aren’t that bright are looked down upon. So, whether a woman is gorgeous or not, in order to obtain “perfection,” she has to have the right combination of smarts and stupidity.

    It sends a mixed message to girls, I think. My little brother doesn’t have perfect-sized sisters, but he still somewhat expects that from his “girlfriends.” He still values women who aren’t perfect, but his expectations leave much to be desired in my opinion.

    Meh. He’s young. There’s still time to knock some sense into him, I suppose. :)

  8. On November 9, 2007 at 5:38 am toby Said:

    Rarity is and probably always will be a significant part of desirability. When the voluptuous woman was an ideal during the renaissance (or modern day Africa) it was every bit as unattainable an ideal as the current thin model. It is impossible for people to be powerfully drawn to average experiences. I think we give the media too much credit in this phenomenon.

  9. On November 9, 2007 at 3:11 pm Darkspell Said:

    Thanks Toby for your comment!

    So do you have any personal experiance of your own with this topic?

  10. On November 9, 2007 at 4:41 pm toby Said:

    I once lived in a tiny, remote village in Tanzania. While there I met a young Tanzanian woman who was the most beautiful I had ever seen. Women in the culture I came from would have killed for her form. And I frequently overheard her bewailing the fact that she was ugly because she was not yet “fat.” This all took place in an area that was as shielded from media as can still be in this world.

    http://ukweli.wordpress.com/2005/05/09/on-the-stone-in-the-rice/trackback/

  11. On November 9, 2007 at 11:32 pm Darkspell Said:

    Thanks Toby!

    I always thought it was interesting where there are some culture’s “beauty” are so different then another’s. Thank you for your insight!

  12. On November 17, 2007 at 1:09 am Cristina Said:

    It wasn’t like I could of “avoided” having an Eating Disorder. It’s not a “choice”.

  13. On January 9, 2008 at 6:02 pm bobarb26 Said:

    I’m doing a project that asks men to submit their description of the perfect woman for them… so far the submissions are pretty interesting…

    Check it out: http://www.perfectwomanproject.com

    Thanks,
    -Your Perfect Woman

Leave a Comment